Thank you! Based on your answers, here is what your symptoms may indicate:
While only a physical exam and imaging (like an X-ray or MRI) can provide a definitive diagnosis, your symptoms generally fall into one of the following categories:

Profile A: Degenerative or Wear-and-Tear (Potential Osteoarthritis)
If you feel:
- Pain that is worse in the morning or after resting.
- A gradual onset of pain over months or years.
- Stiffness or a “grinding” sensation (crepitus).
- Age 50+ or a history of “bowed” legs.
What this means: These are classic signs of osteoarthritis, where the protective cartilage in the joint wears down. This often leads to our Joint Replacement pathways, including minimally invasive total or partial knee replacements.
Profile B: Acute or Mechanical Injury (Potential Meniscus or ACL Tear)
If you feel:
- A sudden “pop” or twist followed by swelling.
- Feelings of instability or the knee “giving out.”
- Mechanical symptoms like “locking” or “catching” when you walk.
- Pain located specifically along the joint line (the sides of the knee).
What this means: These symptoms often point to structural damage such as a meniscus tear or a ligament injury (ACL/MCL). These cases are typically handled by a knee specialist, focusing on arthroscopic repair and returning you to an active lifestyle.
Profile C: Overuse or Tracking Issues (Potential Runner’s Knee or Tendonitis)
If you feel:
- Pain located primarily at the front of the knee or under the kneecap.
- Increased pain when climbing stairs, squatting, or sitting for long periods.
- Dull, aching pain rather than a sharp “locking” sensation.
What this means: This often indicates Patellofemoral Pain Syndrome or Tendonitis. It is usually caused by the kneecap not tracking properly or inflammation of the tendons. Many of these cases respond exceptionally well to specialized physical therapy.
Next Steps: Don’t let the pain become permanent.
Regardless of which profile fits you best, persistent knee pain rarely resolves itself without a targeted plan. Early intervention can often mean the difference between a simple repair and a more complex procedure later. Call (812) 945-5633 to request an appointment or click below to book online.
Educational Resources for You:
- Deep Dive: Total vs. Partial Knee Replacement – Which is Right for You?
- Discover More: What is a Total Knee Replacement
- Recovery: What Happens After Knee Replacement
Schedule a Consultation Today
Take the first step toward making pain a memory today. Fill out the information below and a member of our team will be in touch to schedule a consultation with Dr. Clegg.